Do you select Agile? Six Sigma? How do encourage change? Steve Macaulay shares his insight

From Six Sigma to Lean, Agile, and employee engagement¹, many strategies promise to transform organisations by improving efficiency, quality, and customer satisfaction, and ensuring employees are motivated and committed. A well-implemented framework can indeed help organisations deliver high-quality products, adapt to change, and maintain a competitive edge.

Before implementing any new approach, it’s essential to identify your organisation’s underlying issues

However, leaders often rightly ask, “Will it work for us?” With so many methodologies available, and promises bandied around, choosing the best one can be challenging. This article explores how to evaluate, tailor, and implement new strategies to maximise their potential, focusing on the role of HR and L&D.

Diagnosing the issue

Before implementing any new approach, it’s essential to identify your organisation’s underlying issues. This requires a thorough diagnostic process, including performance assessments, employee feedback, and workflow analysis. HR should be important here in facilitating discussion and analysis. Neglecting this step can lead to misaligned expectations and disappointing outcomes. Alarmingly, this can happen all too often.

As an example of a company anticipating these issues and to counter this danger, a call centre facing high turnover and poor performance used a comprehensive diagnostic process. It engaged employees at all levels to identify root causes. Agile principles were used throughout and tailored solutions, resulting in a year-long transformation. The success stemmed from a thorough understanding and commitment, plus adapting proven methods to the organisation’s specific needs.

Selecting the right approach

Choosing the right framework involves evaluating its alignment with your organisation’s culture, goals, and resources. It’s crucial to ensure the approach fits strategically and is compatible with employee values.

Reviewing the success of frameworks across similar industries can provide valuable insights. Consider factors like scalability and available resources to ensure successful implementation.

Testing and adapting solutions

Organisations often stumble when applying a one-size-fits-all framework. Pilot programmes offer a way to test new strategies on a smaller scale before rolling them out organisation-wide. This allows you to refine the approach based on feedback, ensuring it fits your organisation’s context.

For instance, Lean principles initially struggled in healthcare settings until they were adapted to focus on patient flow and waste reduction, demonstrating the importance of tailoring solutions.

Overcoming common barriers

Resistance to change is a common obstacle, often due to cultural inertia, tight budgets, or time constraints. Leaders can work to overcome these challenges by actively championing the initiative, communicating its value, and involving employees. Providing training, celebrating small wins, and creating a supportive environment can help build trust and foster a positive culture.

A committed change management team can further reinforce these efforts, ensuring sustained motivation. However, as a warning signal, one organisation installed “change champions” in each division without consultation, leading to resistance and a lack of cooperation in some divisions, despite an urgent need to change.

Learning from industry leaders

Companies like Toyota, Amazon, Google, and Netflix offer valuable lessons in successfully adopting and sustaining change. Toyota’s Kaizen, Amazon’s customer obsession, and Google’s focus on employee empowerment are examples of continuous improvement and innovation.

While straight replicating these companies may not be feasible or desirable, adapting their principles to your organisation’s needs can lead to significant benefits.

Guiding principles for a new approach

To succeed, organisations should define core values that align with their goals and adapt frameworks to suit their unique challenges. Encouraging employee contributions fosters an engaged workforce while maintaining a strong focus on customer needs to ensure relevance.

Regularly measuring outcomes and using data analytics to guide decisions is essential for long-term success. Fostering a culture of experimentation and adaptability ensures that the organisation can sustain progress and drive innovation.

The role of HR and L&D

HR and L&D are often key to the success of improvement methodologies. Here’s how they contribute:

• Training and skill development: HR and L&D equip employees with the necessary skills to implement and sustain frameworks like Lean, Agile, and Six Sigma. This includes both specialised training (e.g., Six Sigma certifications) and broader skills in problem-solving and teamwork.
  
  
• Building a culture of continuous improvement: HR can foster a culture that embraces Lean, Agile, and Six Sigma by promoting values like open communication, collaboration, and continuous learning. These values can be integrated into performance management systems.
  
  
• Employee engagement and ownership: HR and L&D help create an environment where employees feel empowered to participate in improvements. This includes forming cross-functional teams, encouraging idea-sharing, and recognising contributions.
  
  
• Leadership development: HR identifies and develops leaders who can champion improvement initiatives. L&D offers leadership development programmes that impart the skills necessary to lead change, including coaching, mentoring, and managing resistance.
  
  
• Change management support: HR can be prominent in the change management process by communicating the value of new methodologies, addressing concerns, and ensuring buy-in. L&D must be a significant leader in the provision of change management training and resources to help employees adapt.
  
  
• Measuring success and providing feedback: HR can build feedback mechanisms into its performance management systems to track the effectiveness of initiatives.

Three key themes are most important:

1. HR and L&D can do much to support Lean, Agile, Six Sigma, and engagement initiatives through training, leadership development, and continuous improvement.
   
   
2. Concentrate upfront on diagnosing challenges, selecting a “good fit” framework, and making adjustments to drive growth and seize opportunities.
   
   
3. Go into this with your eyes open: you may well encounter early cynicism and later on new, attractive alternatives will shout loudly. Overcome challenges by adapting management strategies to fit the organisation’s unique needs.

Reference

1. Quick Overview of Improvement Methodologies

Lean, Agile, and Six Sigma are process improvement methodologies that share common principles, including a focus on customer value, continuous improvement, data-driven decision-making, team collaboration, and the elimination of waste and inefficiencies.

Employee engagement plays a crucial role in the success of each framework, which emphasises the active involvement of employees in improvement and decision-making.

Lean emphasises waste reduction to enhance customer value.

Agile prioritises iterative delivery with feedback.

Six Sigma aims to improve quality through statistical methods and defect reduction.

All three encourage integrating customer feedback and empowering teams. Despite their similarities, they differ in their focus: Lean targets efficiency, Agile adapts to change quickly, and Six Sigma focuses on quality control through data analysis.

---

Steve Macaulay is an Associate of Cranfield Executive Development