Could your AI side hustle put your freelance status at risk?

AI training platforms are opening up new earning opportunities for independent L&D professionals, but attractive hourly rates may conceal employment and tax complications. Chris Brower examines the legal challenges facing these platforms and explains why freelancers need to look beyond the pay cheque before signing up for this growing market.

Job boards now carry a steady stream of roles with titles like “AI trainer,” “rubric writer” and “prompt evaluator”, paying anywhere from £20 to £80 an hour and openly recruiting people with backgrounds in teaching, assessment design and curriculum development. For a freelance instructional designer or facilitator watching corporate training budgets tighten, that looks like a natural extension of the work they already do: writing rubrics, calibrating markers, deciding whether an answer meets a standard.

The skills match is real. What deserves more scrutiny is the structure of the work itself, because several of the platforms offering it are currently being challenged in court over how much control they exercise on workers they classify as independent contractors, and the control factors named in those cases are close to ones UK tribunals have already ruled on.

Why this work fits L&D skills so well

AI labs building large language models need people who can write scoring rubrics, calibrate against a marking standard, and give structured feedback on whether an output meets a bar. This is exactly the skillset behind instructional design and assessment work. Platforms marketing this work, including Mercor’s freelance AI training guide, target professionals rather than generalists, and outlets have started describing it as a side hustle for people with this kind of expertise. For someone already freelancing in L&D, it can look like an easy way to use existing skills for a new client.

The same control questions UK courts have already asked

In Uber BV v Aslam, the UK Supreme Court found that Uber’s drivers were “workers”, not independent contractors, based on five factors where Uber:

  1. Fixed the fares with no input from drivers
  2. Set the contract terms unilaterally
  3. Penalised drivers who declined or underperformed
  4. Controlled how the job was done through the app
  5. Stopped drivers building a direct relationship with passengers who might rehire them

Two US class actions against AI training platforms describe a similar pattern. In the first, workers who label data and evaluate model outputs allege that tasks were assigned by algorithm, pay rates were set unilaterally, and unpaid training was required before anyone could earn a wage.

The second makes the same unpaid training claim and adds an automated system that could remove pay entirely if a task ran past a fixed deadline. Neither case has been decided, but the mechanics described, fixed rates, algorithmic task assignment and no ongoing client relationship, map closely onto the factors the UK Supreme Court used to decide Uber’s drivers were workers rather than self-employed contractors.

What to check before you say yes

Before taking on one of these contracts, it is worth asking questions that a corporate L&D client relationship rarely raises:

  • Is the rate genuinely negotiable, or fixed by the platform for every task in the queue?
  • Is calibration or onboarding time paid, or treated as unpaid training?
  • Can tasks be declined without the account being throttled or deactivated?
  • Does the arrangement leave room to operate outside IR35 through a limited company, or does the platform’s control over how the work gets done put it inside?
  • Is there ever a named client to build a relationship with, or only an algorithm assigning the next task?

Beyond the one contract

None of this means the work is a bad idea. Rates can be strong and the work can suit a quiet period between consultancy projects. But stacking a handful of these platforms alongside genuine consultancy clients can complicate a freelancer’s wider employment status and tax position if HMRC or a tribunal later examines how the relationship actually operated, not just what the contract called it. For a freelance L&D professional, the day rate on an AI training platform is only half the calculation. The other half is whether the way the work is structured could change their status as genuinely self-employed, on this contract and on every other one they hold at the same time.


Chris Brower is Co-founder and President, Chief Revenue Officer at HireArt


illuminated must read neon sign

Get Training Journal’s Thursday newsletter straight to your inbox